• Agronomic Information, Seed
  • Nov 30, 2020

Alfalfa Seed Treatments Key to Long-term Stand Productivity

farm hands holding alfalfa

Debates about uncoated, light-coated (9%) and heavy-coated (34%) alfalfa seed are common among seed providers and farmers. Skeptics say there tends to be less seed in a bag of coated seed and therefore farmers get less for their money. They may also claim coated seed requires increased seeding rates to achieve the same stand. But research shows that coated seed can offer substantial benefits for an alfalfa crop.
 

As you’re weighing next season’s alfalfa seed decisions, here are five research-backed insights to consider that demonstrate the effectiveness of treated alfalfa seed.
 

1. Coated seed results in better stands.

Critics of coated seed recommend increasing seeding rates because fewer seeds are planted per square foot. However, coated seed actually has a higher seed-to-seedling success rate than uncoated seed. So fewer seeds are needed to produce a similar stand.

 

Research by Purdue University shows coated seed produced as many seedlings per square foot as uncoated seed (29.5 and 30, respectively) when 21.8 lbs. of alfalfa seed was planted per acre (uncoated = 78 pure live seed [PLS] per square foot and coated = 56 PLS per square foot). They also planted at 14.5 lbs. per acre (uncoated = 52 PLS per square foot and coated = 38 PLS per square foot) and ended up with similar stand counts for each: 31 and 29 seedlings per square foot, respectively.1 The need for fewer seeds can mean reduced seed costs for farmers.

 

2. Coated seed offers better seed-to-soil contact.

Larger farms and bigger farm equipment can mean less time spent preparing seedbeds, resulting in less-than-ideal seed placement with poor seed-to-soil contact. Coated seed offers better moisture absorption and transfer to the seed for germination. The coating material (often lime) attracts water better than the seed itself. This was verified by lab research from the WinField United Innovation Center, where coated seed had about a 12% better germination rate than uncoated seed from the same seed lot.2

 

3. Coated seed provides greater protection against early-season pests.

In a recent study conducted by Forage Genetics International, two sets of three seed treatments (uncoated, 9% coated and 34% coated) were sampled and chemically analyzed for the fungicide active ingredient mefenoxam. In both cases, the rate of fungicide per seed was highest on the 34% coated seed and lowest on the uncoated seed. This makes sense, given that dose recommendations for alfalfa are based on weight, not seeds per pound (Figure 1).3



 

4. Alfalfa seedlings from coated seed have more vigor when disease is present.

Testing under multirace aphanomyces root rot pressure indicated 86% more lateral roots and 16% longer roots when seeds were treated with the fungicide active ingredient and coated compared with uncoated treated seed (Figure 2). The commercial 34%-plus coating provided an additional 12% increase in aphanomyces root rot resistance over the standard 34% coating when comparing overall root health of the seedlings.3



 

5. Coating helps keep products close to the seed.

Experience has shown coating enhances the protective effect of the single fungicide active ingredient and suggests that inoculants, additional fungicides, plant growth regulators and micronutrients are also more effective on coated seeds. As other products are added to the seed treatment, it makes sense to use a coating to keep the beneficial products close to the seed.

Coated seed increases seed efficiency by turning more seeds into healthy plants. Also, farmers generally plant more seed than is needed for a productive stand — most plant more than 15 lbs. per acre, and some plant as much as 25 lbs. per acre. A 15-lb.-per-acre seeding rate at 200,000 seeds per pound (34% coating) is about 45 seeds per square foot. The goal is to have 15 to 20 established plants by fall of seeding year. Even at 15 lbs. per acre, there are more than double the seeds needed to establish a productive stand.

 

Work with your local WinField United retailer to find the right alfalfa seed option for your operation.

 
 

1. Alfalfa and Red Clover Stand Establishment. Forage Management Day at Feldun-Purdue Agricultural Center, Aug. 9, 2018.
2. Study by WinField United Innovation Center, River Falls, WI, 2018.
3. Study by Forage Genetics International, West Salem, WI, 2018.

 

All photos are either the property of WinField United or used with permission.

 

Important: Before use always read and follow label instructions. Crop performance is dependent on several factors many of which are beyond the control of WinField United, including without limitation, soil type, pest pressures, agronomic practices, and weather conditions. Growers are encouraged to consider data from multiple locations, over multiple years, and be mindful of how such agronomic conditions could impact results.

 

© 2020 WinField United. WinField® is a trademark of WinField United.

Thank You for Signing Up.

Get the latest insights and tips – directly to your inbox

Subscribe to our Advisor e-newsletter, keeping you up to date on the latest news, information and agronomic tips in the industry, national and local.

By signing up for WinField United emails, you agree to receive promotional information from WinField United. The emails will contain valuable agronomic insights, the latest WinField United product information and field updates. For more information about our privacy policy, please review it here.

 
 
   
   

Yes, sign me up for my local . ​

Enter your contact details and we’ll start delivering your local report to your inbox, based on the zip code you provide.

 
 
   
   

















































 

Thank you for your request. One of our expert agronomists will be reaching out to you shortly.